|
Post by zekurt on Jun 28, 2020 2:26:13 GMT
If I saw some evidence showing a long period of inactivity (a few months) i would also like to mention this users general inactivity with the mbs and the rest of the discord as well, we have an MB announcement channel which was made for the ecd to tell us about any projects or updates on anything. Nothing has been posted in there since F E B R U A R YThis in my opinion is proof that he is not doing his duty of handling master builder projects, and hasn't for many months.
|
|
|
Post by DragonSlayer2189 on Jun 28, 2020 2:28:00 GMT
If Miwo is under circumstances in which he temporarily cannot access the game in order to manage map creation, but is at least able to manage his forum-related activities, is that truly worthy of a vote off under temporary conditions? If I saw some evidence showing a long period of inactivity (a few months) then I'd be inclined to agree, but if he is temporarily unable to access the server, can that not be chalked up to a temporary inactivity? It would be an unprecedented burden to require somebody to work around circumstances in which they would be unable to access the server, especially given the history of support that Miwo has provided since 2010 related to his position, we should avoid losing somebody with this level of expertise and experience because we won't find somebody who shares it. I'm not defending him not having to do his job, I'm saying that we should be charitable and assume good intent given his consistent handling of his forum-related duties, if he is just not able to access the game. he hasnt done anything on the server, forums, or discord, its been like this since he was added to the role. i dont see your point
|
|
|
Post by Polaris Seltzeris on Jun 28, 2020 2:31:47 GMT
If Miwo is under circumstances in which he temporarily cannot access the game in order to manage map creation, but is at least able to manage his forum-related activities, is that truly worthy of a vote off under temporary conditions? If I saw some evidence showing a long period of inactivity (a few months) then I'd be inclined to agree, but if he is temporarily unable to access the server, can that not be chalked up to a temporary inactivity? It would be an unprecedented burden to require somebody to work around circumstances in which they would be unable to access the server, especially given the history of support that Miwo has provided since 2010 related to his position, we should avoid losing somebody with this level of expertise and experience because we won't find somebody who shares it. I'm not defending him not having to do his job, I'm saying that we should be charitable and assume good intent given his consistent handling of his forum-related duties, if he is just not able to access the game. he hasnt done anything on the server, forums, or discord, its been like this since he was added to the role. i dont see your point Can you show me this? I don't recall a great deal of activity from any creative designer to be honest, but I also haven't seen reports from any executive except for zeseryu.
|
|
|
Post by DragonSlayer2189 on Jun 28, 2020 2:37:32 GMT
he hasnt done anything on the server, forums, or discord, its been like this since he was added to the role. i dont see your point Can you show me this? I don't recall a great deal of activity from any creative designer to be honest, but I also haven't seen reports from any executive except for zeseryu. you can litterly look at his forum account and see the threads that he has made, none of them rly have anything to do with ECD shit
|
|
|
Post by Polaris Seltzeris on Jun 28, 2020 2:40:52 GMT
Can you show me this? I don't recall a great deal of activity from any creative designer to be honest, but I also haven't seen reports from any executive except for zeseryu. you can litterly look at his forum account and see the threads that he has made, none of them rly have anything to do with ECD shit I'm not talking about the forum because I don't expect the ECD to be doing much on there other than the master builder applications which he has handled. If your argument is that he hasn't been on the Minecraft server (which is obviously the important thing here) since February, can you not show evidence of this?
|
|
|
Post by DragonSlayer2189 on Jun 28, 2020 2:53:30 GMT
you can litterly look at his forum account and see the threads that he has made, none of them rly have anything to do with ECD shit I'm not talking about the forum because I don't expect the ECD to be doing much on there other than the master builder applications which he has handled. If your argument is that he hasn't been on the Minecraft server (which is obviously the important thing here) since February, can you not show evidence of this? i never said he hasnt been on since febuary, but he is still extrememly inactive, in fact here is there server activity profilein this you can see that: • miwo last date on the server was Jun 15 2020, 12:47 • since Mar 26 2020 at 19:08 they have a total overall playtime of 1d 12h 53m 18s, more than 10h 7m 46s of that being afk • in the last month they only have ~34 minutes of playtime • has only logged into the server 5 times in the last month • is marked as inactive by the log thingy with a score of 0.67
|
|
|
Post by Polaris Seltzeris on Jun 28, 2020 2:56:59 GMT
I'm not talking about the forum because I don't expect the ECD to be doing much on there other than the master builder applications which he has handled. If your argument is that he hasn't been on the Minecraft server (which is obviously the important thing here) since February, can you not show evidence of this? i never said he hasnt been on since febuary, but he is still extrememly inactive, in fact here is there server activity profilein this you can see that: • miwo last date on the server was Jun 15 2020, 12:47 • since Mar 26 2020 at 19:08 they have a total overall playtime of 1d 12h 53m 18s, more than 10h 7m 46s of that being afk • in the last month they only have ~34 minutes of playtime • has only logged into the server 5 times in the last month • is marked as inactive by the log thingy with a score of 0.67 If he hasn't been active since March then I'll switch my vote to a yes. Always important to use evidence in these threads.
|
|
miwo
Veteran Member
Posts: 597
| Likes: 585
|
Post by miwo on Jun 28, 2020 7:11:19 GMT
Im moving houses right now - as I have said plenty of times before: I literally have no access to my PC atm.
Also: what is the point in implementing the new Exec policy if you are going to enforce it? there hasnt been 3 months since the suggestion for quarterly elections was implemented, which was more or less the reasoning for me not posting a formal thread - I expect internet by mid next week
|
|
miwo
Veteran Member
Posts: 597
| Likes: 585
|
Post by miwo on Jun 28, 2020 7:19:39 GMT
i would also like to mention this users general inactivity with the mbs and the rest of the discord as well, we have an MB announcement channel which was made for the ecd to tell us about any projects or updates on anything. Nothing has been posted in there since F E B R U A R Yand while miwo has made a few comments about other things, they haven't done anything related to any ECD actions in quite a while. they also don't have their admin rank as their display group which is very concerning considering that this is the person who is supposed to be in charge of the MBS and other creative processes, and their only actual action as an ecd was thisIsnt this a falsehood? I still actively manage applicants, and I posted there half a week ago? Also I thinks its quite sad if you think my only contribution as ECD was asking to remove the world - simply not true
|
|
fionn
Club 4000 Member
Admin Officer
elmon sucks
Posts: 6,157
| Likes: 4,775
|
Post by fionn on Jun 28, 2020 7:24:00 GMT
i would also like to mention this users general inactivity with the mbs and the rest of the discord as well, we have an MB announcement channel which was made for the ecd to tell us about any projects or updates on anything. Nothing has been posted in there since F E B R U A R Yand while miwo has made a few comments about other things, they haven't done anything related to any ECD actions in quite a while. they also don't have their admin rank as their display group which is very concerning considering that this is the person who is supposed to be in charge of the MBS and other creative processes, and their only actual action as an ecd was thisIsnt this a falsehood? I still actively manage applicants, and I posted there half a week ago? Also I thinks its quite sad if you think my only contribution as ECD was asking to remove the world - simply not true out of general curiosity, what else have you done? i haven't been keeping up in the masterbuilder scene at all and i'm not sure what you've done. maybe listing some of your achievements as masterbuilder may help sway the vote?
|
|
miwo
Veteran Member
Posts: 597
| Likes: 585
|
Post by miwo on Jun 28, 2020 7:24:47 GMT
Isnt this a falsehood? I still actively manage applicants, and I posted there half a week ago? Also I thinks its quite sad if you think my only contribution as ECD was asking to remove the world - simply not true out of general curiosity, what else have you done? i haven't been keeping up in the masterbuilder scene at all and i'm not sure what you've done. maybe listing some of your achievements as masterbuilder may help sway the vote? if people dislike me as ECD then thats just how it is, but sure: - made the MB rank - was and still is the most active MB to date - have contribjted the most amount of spawns, maps and builds in general to TF - have organized the MBs 5 different times to get spawns built - 4 of these were griefed due to a lack of grief protection, and now we are working on 2 new ones - the entire MB policy as of now is basically my writing. - I actively recruit new MBs when I play on the server, I also invite plenty of builders I know on to help as well. - there is not a single MB now that has not been promoted by me - the current MB spawn is almost finished - this spawn was made by the only 2-4 active MBs at that tine (incl. Me). Im on a phone now so I wont give a much more detailed list, but heres what im working on - MB apprenticeship - complete rework of the MB policies (e.g. activity, VS use etc) - finishing of the MB spawn and start of the Hub spawn But again, werent these elections supposed to be held every 3 months to make sure these call-out threads werent nessecary, making this entire thread redundant?
|
|
fionn
Club 4000 Member
Admin Officer
elmon sucks
Posts: 6,157
| Likes: 4,775
|
Post by fionn on Jun 28, 2020 7:32:28 GMT
- was and still is the most active MB to date i'm not sure where you're getting that from but statistically you're one of the most activity-lacking admins on the server if people dislike me as ECD people don't dislike you as ecd, they'd just like to see more of you, and due to your recent inactivity we haven't been able to see that - have contribjted the most amount of spawns, maps and builds in general to TF mind giving examples? - I actively recruit new MBs when I play on the server, I also invite plenty of builders I know on to help as well. that's generally to be expected of an ecd Miwo I like you, genuinely I really do like you, but community interaction is everything and the community has not been getting sufficient communication with you during these past few weeks.
|
|
miwo
Veteran Member
Posts: 597
| Likes: 585
|
Post by miwo on Jun 28, 2020 7:35:59 GMT
- was and still is the most active MB to date i'm not sure where you're getting that from but statistically you're one of the most activity-lacking admins on the server if people dislike me as ECD people don't dislike you as ecd, they'd just like to see more of you, and due to your recent inactivity we haven't been able to see that - have contribjted the most amount of spawns, maps and builds in general to TF mind giving examples? - I actively recruit new MBs when I play on the server, I also invite plenty of builders I know on to help as well. that's generally to be expected of an ecd Miwo I like you, genuinely I really do like you, but community interaction is everything and the community has not been getting sufficient communication with you during these past few weeks. Quite disingenious to show my activity from the last few months when I already noted I am in the midst of moving homes - Again if you want somebody else for this position, then you should vote me off at thr appropriate time per the new policy, which would be in 1-2 months. I dont see why this thread should be taken seriously other than pointing out my lack of inactivity which I have already explained why before in other forums and now here.
|
|
fionn
Club 4000 Member
Admin Officer
elmon sucks
Posts: 6,157
| Likes: 4,775
|
Post by fionn on Jun 28, 2020 7:37:04 GMT
i'm not sure where you're getting that from but statistically you're one of the most activity-lacking admins on the server people don't dislike you as ecd, they'd just like to see more of you, and due to your recent inactivity we haven't been able to see that mind giving examples? that's generally to be expected of an ecd Miwo I like you, genuinely I really do like you, but community interaction is everything and the community has not been getting sufficient communication with you during these past few weeks. Quitr disingenious to show my activity from the last few months when I already noted I am in the midst of moving homes. it was not my general intent to be disingenious i was simply disputing your "I was and still am the most active Master Builder"
|
|
miwo
Veteran Member
Posts: 597
| Likes: 585
|
Post by miwo on Jun 28, 2020 7:38:46 GMT
Quitr disingenious to show my activity from the last few months when I already noted I am in the midst of moving homes. it was not my general intent to be disingenious i was simply disputing your "I was and still am the most active Master Builder" Name a single MB or Admin that has played consistently and as much as I since 2010.
|
|