Email Appeal - Wilee

Why? A discussion is clearly merited regardless 

You say unproductive, I say the opposite. This is a ban appeal in which Wilee is appealing his ban on the basis that he finds it illegitimate, and people are still vouching for this viewpoint. According to your logic Wilee should've stayed banned the countless other times he was wrongfully banned by Seth, because that was the "final verdict".

It shows that some people in the community are willing to try and weasel their way around rules in order to prevent themselves from having to take any actual responsibility.

Look, no one is stopping you from making threads contesting this verdict. However, by the looks of this thread, it does not seem like many will support you. You've also not answered my question: what productive outcome has this discussion led to?

What was the point of this reply? Darth was clearly commenting on Wilee. Stop trying to stir shit up when you can clearly tell who the comment was directed towards.

Anyways, I see no point of engaging in this thread anymore. It's a permban appeal. The majority is against. That says enough. 

Wilee wrote several paragraphs on why he thinks he didn't do anything wrong when it's quite clear to most of the voters on this thread that he did. Then, a handful of people are attempting to back up his claims that he did nothing wrong (on a technical level). Whether or not Wilee can see this is irrelevant, given that his own words (the original appeal he wrote himself) sparked a whole discussion on why he did/didn't break the rules. 

And for the Nth time, Video apologized for his actions and admitted his wrongdoing. Wilee did not. That is the difference. 

Sorry, by 'You' I meant you and everyone else who is arguing this is an acceptable outcome. You cannot enforce a rule for a TF platform in a non TF Environment, they are not bound by our rules when they choose to do stuff in their own time, it's as simple as that. Neither party broke the rules, and technically speaking, there was no Dox that occurred when you look at the definition of a dox.





We've seen no information either of those were broken here, and even if they were, for the last time. It did not happen on a TF Platform and therefore is nothing to do with this server. Even if you did decide you want a piece of the pie, it contradicts Seth's own statement that he is no longer banning people from multiple platforms.

You cannot expect to selectively enforce rules because you don't like the person who's being sanctioned today, and do like someone else that broke the rule tomorrow.

It's only "Weasel"ing out of the rules if you broke the rules in the first place, which he has said and proven wasn't the case by our own rules, and the rules are contradicted. The sanction was not proportional to the offence that occurred and is in direct violation of the forum posting guidelines.