Post by _Windows on Apr 18, 2016 23:07:29 GMT
1. Approx date and time you suspended the admin.
At the time of this post.
2. Why you suspended the admin - include relevant log entries
Abuse, see the spoiler below for relevant evidence. At no point during the undercover session did I violate any rule. In fact, I even tried to assist the admins some.
3. Did you attempt to correct the admin before suspending him/her?
Attempts have been made within the past week to get this admin to stop banning for unfair reasons (i.e. banning out of suspicion).
4. Did you notify the admin that you removed them from and why?
No.
5. If you answered no to either 3 or 4, please explain. Except in extreme case such as the admin going rogue and trying to crash the server or if you were undercover, I would expect yes answers for both.
I was undercover.
The following threads explain what motivated me to investigate FaZeMelonKing .
totalfreedom.boards.net/thread/38479/fazemelonking
totalfreedom.boards.net/thread/38504/fazemelonking
Today, I went undercover with the most generic name: Player, on a VPN. The purpose of this was to observe FaZeMelonKing from the perspective of a non-troll OP. In order to present a differing personality from my own, I injected some harmless immaturity (a twist on a meme, specifically mentioning shoop da woop in the chat). I also tested a few basic commands like a normal op would do. In addition, I used /summon to light up a few nether portals (note: nether portals do not cause any lag). What I was doing was an advanced build technique to ignite a portal as op. Also, note that there was a delay between my use of /summon such that it did not spam the chat. I even set a warp and invited people to come see this lit-nether-portal structure I made. In addition I complimented another admin on their build that I saw. Clearly, doing everything one would expect a nice, non-troll op to do.
And what happens? Shortly after I disconnect, a glist ban on my undercover person. This pretty clearly proves that FaZeMelonKing is banning players for no valid reason (and even in fact, banning HELPFUL players). Note also that at no point did FaZeMelonKing ask/warn. In my eyes, this is clear abuse, especially since he waited until disconnect to do the ban.
[22:11:50] [Server thread/INFO]: [TotalFreedomMod] [ADMIN] FaZeMelonKing [SA]: Watch out for Player
[22:12:17] [User Authenticator #370/INFO]: UUID of player XEnderWither is b6243b8d-0653-36bc-96c3-8aa576f41b0e
[22:12:25] [User Authenticator #371/INFO]: UUID of player Star_Warz is 6e39f472-991f-3791-b19b-28f1484e018d
[22:12:33] [Server thread/INFO]: FaZeMelonKing issued server command: /tp Player
[22:12:36] [Server thread/INFO]: FaZeMelonKing issued server command: /tpo Player
[22:13:04] [User Authenticator #372/INFO]: UUID of player jmm1121 is 5cff262c-f4f1-3f6d-b95a-8c2d9f72dd54
[22:13:04] [Server thread/INFO]: [TotalFreedomMod] Creating new player data entry for jmm1121
[22:13:29] [Server thread/INFO]: FaZeMelonKing issued server command: /tp Player
[22:13:31] [Server thread/INFO]: FaZeMelonKing issued server command: /tpo Player
[22:13:47] [User Authenticator #373/INFO]: UUID of player FireCrystal12 is 25b2aefc-95f3-3191-9986-0303ca8aaf66
[22:14:09] [User Authenticator #374/INFO]: UUID of player luiso22 is 62c57449-0481-37e7-91af-5667deb1670a
[22:14:09] [Server thread/INFO]: [TotalFreedomMod] Creating new player data entry for luiso22
[22:14:49] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /summon FallingSand ~ ~ ~ {Block:fire,Data:0,Time:1,DropItem:0}
[22:14:49] [Server thread/INFO]: [Player: Object successfully summoned]
[22:15:01] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /who
[22:15:08] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /seen xfilez
[22:15:10] [Server thread/INFO]: FaZeMelonKing issued server command: /tp Player
[22:15:12] [Server thread/INFO]: FaZeMelonKing issued server command: /tpo Player
[22:15:18] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /radar
[22:15:39] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /summon FallingSand ~ ~ ~ {Block:fire,Data:0,Time:1,DropItem:0}
[22:15:39] [Server thread/INFO]: [Player: Object successfully summoned]
[22:15:50] [User Authenticator #375/INFO]: UUID of player Star_Warz is 6e39f472-991f-3791-b19b-28f1484e018d
[22:15:51] [Server thread/INFO]: FaZeMelonKing issued server command: /tp Player
[22:15:53] [Server thread/INFO]: FaZeMelonKing issued server command: /tpo Player
[22:16:15] [User Authenticator #376/INFO]: UUID of player auston89 is c83ecb49-324c-3070-8523-80ce102823aa
[22:16:29] [User Authenticator #377/INFO]: UUID of player Gracigamer192 is a455d5ca-1063-39a5-8925-1160fcb8bb55
[22:16:46] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /summon FallingSand ~ ~ ~ {Block:fire,Data:0,Time:1,DropItem:0}
[22:16:46] [Server thread/INFO]: [Player: Object successfully summoned]
[22:16:52] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /summon FallingSand ~ ~ ~ {Block:fire,Data:0,Time:1,DropItem:0}
[22:16:52] [Server thread/INFO]: [Player: Object successfully summoned]
[22:16:56] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /summon FallingSand ~ ~ ~ {Block:fire,Data:0,Time:1,DropItem:0}
[22:16:56] [Server thread/INFO]: [Player: Object successfully summoned]
[22:16:58] [User Authenticator #378/INFO]: UUID of player CrazyEndeman9 is 5b4cc7d0-46f1-3411-ae8c-c4b3d24cc9c6
[22:17:06] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /summon FallingSand ~ ~ ~ {Block:fire,Data:0,Time:1,DropItem:0}
[22:17:06] [Server thread/INFO]: [Player: Object successfully summoned]
[22:17:22] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: //wand
[22:17:22] [Server thread/INFO]: WorldEdit: Player (in "flatlands"): /wand
[22:17:45] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: //copy obsidian_portal
[22:17:53] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: //copy
[22:17:53] [Server thread/INFO]: WorldEdit: Player (in "flatlands"): /copy
[22:18:02] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: //schem save obsidian_portal
[22:18:02] [Server thread/INFO]: WorldEdit: Player (in "flatlands"): save obsidian_portal
[22:18:02] [Server thread/INFO]: [WorldEdit] Player saved /.rw/games/minecraft/beta/299668/plugins/WorldEdit/schematics/obsidian_portal.schematic
[22:18:07] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: //paste
[22:18:07] [Server thread/INFO]: WorldEdit: Player (in "flatlands"): /paste - Position: (138.0, 50.0, 0.0)
[22:18:11] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: //undo
[22:18:11] [Server thread/INFO]: WorldEdit: Player (in "flatlands"): /undo
[22:18:36] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: //set
[22:18:43] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: //help set
[22:18:43] [Server thread/INFO]: WorldEdit: Player (in "flatlands"): /help set
[22:18:49] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: //help hsphere
[22:18:49] [Server thread/INFO]: WorldEdit: Player (in "flatlands"): /help hsphere
[22:18:58] [User Authenticator #379/INFO]: UUID of player EthanHDGaming25 is 9afa337b-3a81-3c39-a4a5-d6e8932354f2
[22:19:05] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /radar
[22:19:29] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /setwarp 3dportal
[22:19:40] [Async Chat Thread - #2/INFO]: <Player> everyone /warp 3dportal
[22:19:45] [Server thread/INFO]: mark124 issued server command: /t Player
[22:20:10] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /who
[22:20:13] [User Authenticator #380/INFO]: UUID of player savnith@gmail.co is 7f03cfb8-bfc4-3478-9a13-663e757de196
[22:20:14] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /seen xfilez
[22:20:21] [User Authenticator #381/INFO]: UUID of player __Crafted is 10a0ab0a-51df-385a-bbd7-71c9aa1eb3f2
[22:20:27] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /report XEnderWither imposter for > 5 minutes
[22:20:35] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /report xfilez imposter for > 5 minutes
[22:20:44] [Async Chat Thread - #2/INFO]: <Player> sorry for bad report first time admins
[22:20:59] [User Authenticator #382/INFO]: UUID of player KillSkill is 172b68b9-7164-3f5d-9606-6c9e7d0d868e
[22:21:08] [Server thread/INFO]: Player lost connection: Disconnected
[22:21:08] [Server thread/INFO]: Player left the game.
[22:21:13] [User Authenticator #383/INFO]: UUID of player gavalax is 41e34e45-d57c-3b1e-9ff0-e314d1574c8d
[22:21:17] [Server thread/INFO]: FaZeMelonKing issued server command: /glist ban Player
[22:21:17] [Server thread/INFO]: FaZeMelonKing - Banning Player and IPs: 124.219.174.102
At the time of this post.
2. Why you suspended the admin - include relevant log entries
Abuse, see the spoiler below for relevant evidence. At no point during the undercover session did I violate any rule. In fact, I even tried to assist the admins some.
3. Did you attempt to correct the admin before suspending him/her?
Attempts have been made within the past week to get this admin to stop banning for unfair reasons (i.e. banning out of suspicion).
4. Did you notify the admin that you removed them from and why?
No.
5. If you answered no to either 3 or 4, please explain. Except in extreme case such as the admin going rogue and trying to crash the server or if you were undercover, I would expect yes answers for both.
I was undercover.
The following threads explain what motivated me to investigate FaZeMelonKing .
totalfreedom.boards.net/thread/38479/fazemelonking
totalfreedom.boards.net/thread/38504/fazemelonking
Today, I went undercover with the most generic name: Player, on a VPN. The purpose of this was to observe FaZeMelonKing from the perspective of a non-troll OP. In order to present a differing personality from my own, I injected some harmless immaturity (a twist on a meme, specifically mentioning shoop da woop in the chat). I also tested a few basic commands like a normal op would do. In addition, I used /summon to light up a few nether portals (note: nether portals do not cause any lag). What I was doing was an advanced build technique to ignite a portal as op. Also, note that there was a delay between my use of /summon such that it did not spam the chat. I even set a warp and invited people to come see this lit-nether-portal structure I made. In addition I complimented another admin on their build that I saw. Clearly, doing everything one would expect a nice, non-troll op to do.
And what happens? Shortly after I disconnect, a glist ban on my undercover person. This pretty clearly proves that FaZeMelonKing is banning players for no valid reason (and even in fact, banning HELPFUL players). Note also that at no point did FaZeMelonKing ask/warn. In my eyes, this is clear abuse, especially since he waited until disconnect to do the ban.
[22:11:50] [Server thread/INFO]: [TotalFreedomMod] [ADMIN] FaZeMelonKing [SA]: Watch out for Player
[22:12:17] [User Authenticator #370/INFO]: UUID of player XEnderWither is b6243b8d-0653-36bc-96c3-8aa576f41b0e
[22:12:25] [User Authenticator #371/INFO]: UUID of player Star_Warz is 6e39f472-991f-3791-b19b-28f1484e018d
[22:12:33] [Server thread/INFO]: FaZeMelonKing issued server command: /tp Player
[22:12:36] [Server thread/INFO]: FaZeMelonKing issued server command: /tpo Player
[22:13:04] [User Authenticator #372/INFO]: UUID of player jmm1121 is 5cff262c-f4f1-3f6d-b95a-8c2d9f72dd54
[22:13:04] [Server thread/INFO]: [TotalFreedomMod] Creating new player data entry for jmm1121
[22:13:29] [Server thread/INFO]: FaZeMelonKing issued server command: /tp Player
[22:13:31] [Server thread/INFO]: FaZeMelonKing issued server command: /tpo Player
[22:13:47] [User Authenticator #373/INFO]: UUID of player FireCrystal12 is 25b2aefc-95f3-3191-9986-0303ca8aaf66
[22:14:09] [User Authenticator #374/INFO]: UUID of player luiso22 is 62c57449-0481-37e7-91af-5667deb1670a
[22:14:09] [Server thread/INFO]: [TotalFreedomMod] Creating new player data entry for luiso22
[22:14:49] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /summon FallingSand ~ ~ ~ {Block:fire,Data:0,Time:1,DropItem:0}
[22:14:49] [Server thread/INFO]: [Player: Object successfully summoned]
[22:15:01] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /who
[22:15:08] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /seen xfilez
[22:15:10] [Server thread/INFO]: FaZeMelonKing issued server command: /tp Player
[22:15:12] [Server thread/INFO]: FaZeMelonKing issued server command: /tpo Player
[22:15:18] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /radar
[22:15:39] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /summon FallingSand ~ ~ ~ {Block:fire,Data:0,Time:1,DropItem:0}
[22:15:39] [Server thread/INFO]: [Player: Object successfully summoned]
[22:15:50] [User Authenticator #375/INFO]: UUID of player Star_Warz is 6e39f472-991f-3791-b19b-28f1484e018d
[22:15:51] [Server thread/INFO]: FaZeMelonKing issued server command: /tp Player
[22:15:53] [Server thread/INFO]: FaZeMelonKing issued server command: /tpo Player
[22:16:15] [User Authenticator #376/INFO]: UUID of player auston89 is c83ecb49-324c-3070-8523-80ce102823aa
[22:16:29] [User Authenticator #377/INFO]: UUID of player Gracigamer192 is a455d5ca-1063-39a5-8925-1160fcb8bb55
[22:16:46] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /summon FallingSand ~ ~ ~ {Block:fire,Data:0,Time:1,DropItem:0}
[22:16:46] [Server thread/INFO]: [Player: Object successfully summoned]
[22:16:52] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /summon FallingSand ~ ~ ~ {Block:fire,Data:0,Time:1,DropItem:0}
[22:16:52] [Server thread/INFO]: [Player: Object successfully summoned]
[22:16:56] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /summon FallingSand ~ ~ ~ {Block:fire,Data:0,Time:1,DropItem:0}
[22:16:56] [Server thread/INFO]: [Player: Object successfully summoned]
[22:16:58] [User Authenticator #378/INFO]: UUID of player CrazyEndeman9 is 5b4cc7d0-46f1-3411-ae8c-c4b3d24cc9c6
[22:17:06] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /summon FallingSand ~ ~ ~ {Block:fire,Data:0,Time:1,DropItem:0}
[22:17:06] [Server thread/INFO]: [Player: Object successfully summoned]
[22:17:22] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: //wand
[22:17:22] [Server thread/INFO]: WorldEdit: Player (in "flatlands"): /wand
[22:17:45] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: //copy obsidian_portal
[22:17:53] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: //copy
[22:17:53] [Server thread/INFO]: WorldEdit: Player (in "flatlands"): /copy
[22:18:02] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: //schem save obsidian_portal
[22:18:02] [Server thread/INFO]: WorldEdit: Player (in "flatlands"): save obsidian_portal
[22:18:02] [Server thread/INFO]: [WorldEdit] Player saved /.rw/games/minecraft/beta/299668/plugins/WorldEdit/schematics/obsidian_portal.schematic
[22:18:07] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: //paste
[22:18:07] [Server thread/INFO]: WorldEdit: Player (in "flatlands"): /paste - Position: (138.0, 50.0, 0.0)
[22:18:11] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: //undo
[22:18:11] [Server thread/INFO]: WorldEdit: Player (in "flatlands"): /undo
[22:18:36] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: //set
[22:18:43] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: //help set
[22:18:43] [Server thread/INFO]: WorldEdit: Player (in "flatlands"): /help set
[22:18:49] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: //help hsphere
[22:18:49] [Server thread/INFO]: WorldEdit: Player (in "flatlands"): /help hsphere
[22:18:58] [User Authenticator #379/INFO]: UUID of player EthanHDGaming25 is 9afa337b-3a81-3c39-a4a5-d6e8932354f2
[22:19:05] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /radar
[22:19:29] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /setwarp 3dportal
[22:19:40] [Async Chat Thread - #2/INFO]: <Player> everyone /warp 3dportal
[22:19:45] [Server thread/INFO]: mark124 issued server command: /t Player
[22:20:10] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /who
[22:20:13] [User Authenticator #380/INFO]: UUID of player savnith@gmail.co is 7f03cfb8-bfc4-3478-9a13-663e757de196
[22:20:14] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /seen xfilez
[22:20:21] [User Authenticator #381/INFO]: UUID of player __Crafted is 10a0ab0a-51df-385a-bbd7-71c9aa1eb3f2
[22:20:27] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /report XEnderWither imposter for > 5 minutes
[22:20:35] [Server thread/INFO]: Player issued server command: /report xfilez imposter for > 5 minutes
[22:20:44] [Async Chat Thread - #2/INFO]: <Player> sorry for bad report first time admins
[22:20:59] [User Authenticator #382/INFO]: UUID of player KillSkill is 172b68b9-7164-3f5d-9606-6c9e7d0d868e
[22:21:08] [Server thread/INFO]: Player lost connection: Disconnected
[22:21:08] [Server thread/INFO]: Player left the game.
[22:21:13] [User Authenticator #383/INFO]: UUID of player gavalax is 41e34e45-d57c-3b1e-9ff0-e314d1574c8d
[22:21:17] [Server thread/INFO]: FaZeMelonKing issued server command: /glist ban Player
[22:21:17] [Server thread/INFO]: FaZeMelonKing - Banning Player and IPs: 124.219.174.102
