Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 13, 2019 9:42:03 GMT
What I don't know if the second part of your comment is in relation to the first, but if that's your reasoning behind your vouch then that's quite shitty. We don't really have an exceptionally high standard for master builders here. What we need are reliable, active people that are good at building, and this meets that requirement. There's not much room to be picky here. Who are you to deem what is "exceptionally high standard"? Have you had a look at who the current MBs are, because the standard is certainly higher now, than it has ever been on Total Freedom. The MB team is also meant as training grounds for established builders, yes, but we also need to live up to the our name instead of accepting everybody because they are reliable and active. You also contradict yourself when you say: "We don't really have an exceptionally high standard for master builders here" & "that are good at building" as opposed to: "There's not much room to be picky here."
|
|
|
Post by Polaris Seltzeris on Aug 13, 2019 19:17:47 GMT
We don't really have an exceptionally high standard for master builders here. What we need are reliable, active people that are good at building, and this meets that requirement. There's not much room to be picky here. Who are you to deem what is "exceptionally high standard"? Have you had a look at who the current MBs are, because the standard is certainly higher now, than it has ever been on Total Freedom. The MB team is also meant as training grounds for established builders, yes, but we also need to live up to the our name instead of accepting everybody because they are reliable and active. You also contradict yourself when you say: "We don't really have an exceptionally high standard for master builders here" & "that are good at building" as opposed to: "There's not much room to be picky here." You're misunderstanding what I'm saying. I'm not vouching to an applicant that built a shitty house and then chose to apply, I'm vouching to somebody who provided several images of builds that are at the very least on the same standard of other people that have applied and been approved by you. And yes, activity is a factor alongside that when multiple people on the forums with the rank are dead inactive, but was not the only factor. Not sure how that's a contradiction at all unless you believe being "good at building" (which is subjective) is an exceptionally high standard.
|
|
kai
Veteran Member
if she dont play the craft she don't get the shaft
Posts: 1,022
| Likes: 1,374
|
Post by kai on Aug 13, 2019 19:29:37 GMT
on second thought, i revoke my application.
|
|
Zaid
Veteran Member
When it is said to them, "Do not cause corruption on the earth," they say, "We are but reformers."
Posts: 3,007
|
Post by Zaid on Aug 13, 2019 19:46:48 GMT
on second thought, i revoke my application. Kaitlin....
|
|
Darth
Veteran Member
Server Liaison
Posts: 2,534
| Likes: 1,826
|
Post by Darth on Aug 13, 2019 20:08:30 GMT
miwo why are you being to meticulous here? The last person to apply showed off only one project, with less screenshots, and the first reply to his application was you approving it.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 13, 2019 20:45:05 GMT
miwo why are you being to meticulous here? The last person to apply showed off only one project, with less screenshots, and the first reply to his application was you approving it. Because I saw their builds ingame and I asked them to formally apply before accepting them to the MB team - I never denied this application, I was merely asking for pictures provided without shaders, as have been the case for the majority of all MB apps until now. If Kai can't handle the process, then perhaps she doesn't deserve MB? I haven't even critiqued any of her builds I merely asked for 1) more screenshots 2) screenshots with no shaders. If you don't believe me when I say that I have a constistent record of asking for pics without shaders, then you're more than free to go through all MB apps and call me out if you think I am being unfair. But I'll happily tell what I find good and bad about the applicant's profil e Edit: Screenshot i.imgur.com/WXa8DSa.pngShows no real scope of the build - we get an interior with a basic stairway, boring floor, nice chandelier, almost no minor detail to found. (also shaders make it look 10x better) i.imgur.com/7gn2R2I.pngNice layout, but again - no real detail and we only get 3 colours which don't mix in well at all (also shaders make it look 10x better) i.imgur.com/N2cPjtu.pngsee this is really nice - there's a clear distinction between every building and the colour pallette actually goes pretty well together. (also shaders make it look 10x better) i.imgur.com/smFUNki.pngI have no idea what this is and frankly is a very boring building - only 2 standout colours that don't mix well together. Also the entire shape of the building is pretty bad. (also shaders make it look 10x better) i.imgur.com/DJSlLas.pngIf I were to base the entire app on this build alone, then yeah, I would definitely deny it. one boring colour pallete and a very basic shape. (also shaders make it look 10x better) i.imgur.com/IbCHjO0.pngRed wool and brick don't mix well at all - no real details in the back or front, so your eyes get bored after 5 secnods of looking at it. A colour pallete consisting of 3 colours. Love the chair and table design + the entrance (also shaders make it look 10x better) i.imgur.com/o1Cc5X6.pngA picture taken from 100+ blocks away - smart way to show off any minor details to your build. The actual building looks kinda nice (apart from the build on the right), but I can't judge it based on this picture alone) (also shaders make it look 10x better) i.imgur.com/l80BEfH.pngYOU. DON'T. USE. BLOCKS. WITH. OUTLINES. LIKE. THIS. If you stack blocks with 'outlines' in this manner it makes it look very chaotic and unappealing to the eye - if you want a fence/wall design you use blocks with lines going horizontally or vertically, making the wall/fence looks shorter/taller and givinng it a nice pattern. The building itself is fine, and if this was the standard throughout the applcation I would've probably approved it. (also shaders make it look 10x better) i.imgur.com/9Jz6RQI.pngToo much purple - nice shape for the building. The final verdict would indeed be me denying the application if kai were to not provide any pictures with shaders. Even tozzit mentioned this in the start of the thread.
|
|
?Robin
Club 4000 Member
caleb get off of tf
Posts: 8,027
| Likes: 8,604
|
Post by ?Robin on Aug 14, 2019 0:59:59 GMT
miwo why are you being to meticulous here? The last person to apply showed off only one project, with less screenshots, and the first reply to his application was you approving it. Because I saw their builds ingame and I asked them to formally apply before accepting them to the MB team - I never denied this application, I was merely asking for pictures provided without shaders, as have been the case for the majority of all MB apps until now. If Kai can't handle the process, then perhaps she doesn't deserve MB? I haven't even critiqued any of her builds I merely asked for 1) more screenshots 2) screenshots with no shaders. If you don't believe me when I say that I have a constistent record of asking for pics without shaders, then you're more than free to go through all MB apps and call me out if you think I am being unfair. But I'll happily tell what I find good and bad about the applicant's profil e Edit: Screenshot i.imgur.com/WXa8DSa.pngShows no real scope of the build - we get an interior with a basic stairway, boring floor, nice chandelier, almost no minor detail to found. (also shaders make it look 10x better) i.imgur.com/7gn2R2I.pngNice layout, but again - no real detail and we only get 3 colours which don't mix in well at all (also shaders make it look 10x better) i.imgur.com/N2cPjtu.pngsee this is really nice - there's a clear distinction between every building and the colour pallette actually goes pretty well together. (also shaders make it look 10x better) i.imgur.com/smFUNki.pngI have no idea what this is and frankly is a very boring building - only 2 standout colours that don't mix well together. Also the entire shape of the building is pretty bad. (also shaders make it look 10x better) i.imgur.com/DJSlLas.pngIf I were to base the entire app on this build alone, then yeah, I would definitely deny it. one boring colour pallete and a very basic shape. (also shaders make it look 10x better) i.imgur.com/IbCHjO0.pngRed wool and brick don't mix well at all - no real details in the back or front, so your eyes get bored after 5 secnods of looking at it. A colour pallete consisting of 3 colours. Love the chair and table design + the entrance (also shaders make it look 10x better) i.imgur.com/o1Cc5X6.pngA picture taken from 100+ blocks away - smart way to show off any minor details to your build. The actual building looks kinda nice (apart from the build on the right), but I can't judge it based on this picture alone) (also shaders make it look 10x better) i.imgur.com/l80BEfH.pngYOU. DON'T. USE. BLOCKS. WITH. OUTLINES. LIKE. THIS. If you stack blocks with 'outlines' in this manner it makes it look very chaotic and unappealing to the eye - if you want a fence/wall design you use blocks with lines going horizontally or vertically, making the wall/fence looks shorter/taller and givinng it a nice pattern. The building itself is fine, and if this was the standard throughout the applcation I would've probably approved it. (also shaders make it look 10x better) i.imgur.com/9Jz6RQI.pngToo much purple - nice shape for the building. The final verdict would indeed be me denying the application if kai were to not provide any pictures with shaders. Even tozzit mentioned this in the start of the thread. you're literally canceledt hunty you don't exist tozzit ur time to shine bitch
|
|
|
Post by Mikan Tsumiki - DL108 on Aug 14, 2019 3:10:22 GMT
Second chance for me? I would vouch because unlike miwo, shaders make things look better in some instances. The interiors are not overly detailed, and the fluid design language of the exteriors are smooth enough to be eye-catching.
|
|
Video
Forum Admin
An op's rights activist
Posts: 5,585
| Likes: 5,893
IGN: VideoGameSmash12, videogamesm12
Old IGN: https://namemc.com/profile/VideoGameSmash12.2, https://namemc.com/profile/videogamesm12.1
Discord: Video#9801
Birthdate (MM/DD): 07/16
Timezone: UTC-07:00
Member is Staff. Need immediate assistance? Send a PM
|
Post by Video on Aug 14, 2019 3:24:48 GMT
Vouch. I'd like to use this post as an opportunity to point out an inconsistency that I have noticed in this thread. A complaint that Miwo had was that Kai used shaders in her screenshots. However, this is incredibly hypocritical considering the fact that all of the screenshots on the server's website (in the masterbuilders page, to be exact) use shaders. Why should we criticize someone for using shaders when we aren't any better? totalfreedom.me/masterbuilders/
|
|
Fleek
Veteran Member
Posts: 3,548
|
Post by Fleek on Aug 14, 2019 3:50:56 GMT
I vouch. The builds are what makes her qualified for master builder.
|
|
prince
Veteran Member
cool
Posts: 435
| Likes: 969
|
Post by prince on Aug 14, 2019 14:52:09 GMT
This thread is amusing
Also vouch et cetera
|
|
|
Post by johnyo on Aug 14, 2019 16:07:36 GMT
I'd like to use this post as an opportunity to point out an inconsistency that I have noticed in this thread. A complaint that Miwo had was that Kai used shaders in her screenshots. However, this is incredibly hypocritical considering the fact that all of the screenshots on the server's website (in the masterbuilders page, to be exact) use shaders. Why should we criticize someone for using shaders when we aren't any better? I wouldn't say that it's hypocritical. One is an application, so it's important the Mb's are able to assess a build for what it's truly worth (and it's easier to do that if the build has no shaders) Also, using no shaders on apps makes it fairer playing field. Because an applicant using shaders would have an advantage over an applicant not using shaders. And the other is a website, which is dedicated purely to aesthetics - so it would be fine for shaders to be used there.
|
|
Darth
Veteran Member
Server Liaison
Posts: 2,534
| Likes: 1,826
|
Post by Darth on Aug 14, 2019 16:29:41 GMT
I'd like to use this post as an opportunity to point out an inconsistency that I have noticed in this thread. A complaint that Miwo had was that Kai used shaders in her screenshots. However, this is incredibly hypocritical considering the fact that all of the screenshots on the server's website (in the masterbuilders page, to be exact) use shaders. Why should we criticize someone for using shaders when we aren't any better? I wouldn't say that it's hypocritical. One is an application, so it's important the Mb's are able to assess a build for what it's truly worth (and it's easier to do that if the build has no shaders) Also, using no shaders on apps makes it fairer playing field. Because an applicant using shaders would have an advantage over an applicant not using shaders. And the other is a website, which is dedicated purely to aesthetics - so it would be fine for shaders to be used there. No, it is hypocritical. Miwo was clearly using the shaders as an excuse to either delay further or deny the application. Also, there is no rule saying you can or can't use shaders on your application.
|
|
tozzit
Veteran Member
Posts: 2,329
| Likes: 1,709
|
Post by tozzit on Aug 29, 2019 23:17:40 GMT
If kai still wants to be masterbuilder - it will be accepted - so you know.. make your mind up smh ur revokes to revokes r hurting my brain
|
|
taah
Club 4000 Member
sick af
Posts: 4,778
| Likes: 2,850
|
Post by taah on Aug 29, 2019 23:54:01 GMT
vouch duh
|
|